Drew Pomeranz: A Career of Peaks, Valleys, and Reinvention

Drew Pomeranz’s career has been a fascinating study in potential, injuries, and adjustments. Drafted 5th overall in 2010 by the Cleveland Indians after a stellar career at Ole Miss, Pomeranz was initially projected as a potential frontline starter. His big frame, plus curveball, and decent fastball velocity held promise, but his early career was marked by inconsistency and struggles to stay healthy.

After brief stints with the Indians and Colorado Rockies, Pomeranz found a modicum of success with the Oakland Athletics in 2014 and 2015, primarily as a reliever. It was a sign of things to come, showcasing his ability to contribute even if not in the role initially envisioned.

His true breakout came in 2016 with the San Diego Padres. Given another opportunity to start, Pomeranz blossomed. He harnessed his stuff, showcasing improved command and consistency, and earned an All-Star selection. His performance caught the eye of the Boston Red Sox, who acquired him at the trade deadline, hoping he’d bolster their playoff push.

Pomeranz’s tenure in Boston was a mixed bag. He had flashes of brilliance, including a strong 2017 season where he posted a 17-6 record. However, nagging injuries, particularly to his forearm, continued to plague him. These injuries limited his effectiveness and availability, ultimately impacting his role with the team.

Following his time in Boston, Pomeranz bounced around to several teams, including the San Francisco Giants and Milwaukee Brewers. It was with the Brewers in 2019 where he fully embraced the role of a high-leverage reliever. This shift proved to be a career revitalizer. He simplified his approach, focusing on maximizing his velocity and employing his signature curveball in shorter bursts. The results were immediate and impressive, showcasing his adaptability and willingness to reinvent himself.

This success led to a lucrative free-agent contract with the San Diego Padres once again. He initially continued his dominant relief pitching, solidifying the Padres’ bullpen. Unfortunately, injuries resurfaced, requiring Tommy John surgery in 2021 and significantly impacting his subsequent seasons. Despite signing a multi-year deal, he struggled to return to form. His final year in San Diego was mired with setbacks, leading to his eventual release.

Drew Pomeranz’s career is a testament to the challenges and rewards of professional baseball. While he didn’t quite reach the heights predicted upon his drafting, he carved out a productive career through adaptability, a willingness to change his role, and a dedication to maximizing his abilities. He showed both the allure and the fragility of the game, demonstrating how quickly a promising trajectory can be altered by unforeseen circumstances, and the importance of resilience in the face of adversity.